Welcome to #HackTheMenu | The Ultimate Collection of Secret Menus
Shake Shack Ice Cream Sandwich

Ice Cream Sandwich | Shake Shack Secret Menu

Shake Shack Ice Cream Sandwich

Shake Shack Ice Cream Sandwich

The Ice Cream Sandwich is something so traditional in America that everyone can picture exactly what you're talking about just from mentioning the words. However, this isn't the case for the Shake Shack Ice Cream Sandwich. No no no, this variant is barely recognizable as an ice cream sandwich at all. Although, it does make more sense when you picture what the term ice cream sandwich should look like. That's because this ice cream sandwich is actually assembled by the customer in a sort of makeshift attempt at an ice cream sandwich. Ask your server for a side of grilled burger buns when you order one of their frozen custards. It's like something that you might see in an episode of MacGyver (more likely MacGruber...) where he miraculously gets the job done with what he can find around him. Anyways, give it a try, you may find that this is something that you actually prefer to a normal ice cream sandwich. In fact, this is kind of like how they make ice cream sandwiches in Singapore. Don't believe us? Google it yourself!

Shake Shack Secret Menu

Shake Shack Logo

The Shake Shack Secret Menu main page!

Shake Shack Menu Prices

Shake Shack Logo

The 2021 Shake Shack Menu Prices.

How to Order

Order a frozen custard and ask for a side of grilled hamburger buns.

What’s The Secret?

Frozen Custard assembled between their grilled burger buns.

Complete List of Shake Shack Secret Menu Items